Answers to USAA’s questions
The last post described USAA’s business model and why they favor member services over profits. This post shares their answers to your questions.
But first, I’ve been reminded that all is not necessarily sweetness & light at USAA HQ. After several days of persistent followup I found a scandalous complaint: the parking at their campus is really really tight. If you arrive behind the rush-hour crowd then you’re subject to a long walk under a brutal Texas sun. It’s so bad that instead of rewarding the best employees with cash bonuses or stock options, they get a reserved parking spot.
Sorry, that’s the nastiest dirt I could dig up. Contact me if you know of any other USAA scandals…
Before I get to the reader questions, let me describe what a roomful of unruly bandwidth-equipped bloggers can do to an unsuspecting conference speaker. One of the first questions about USAA’s financial services was whether they’d be offering business checking accounts. The speaker said that they’d heard the question before, but they didn’t see it as a core benefit to their customers. The blogger nodded her head and resumed tapping away at her netbook while he moved on to the next question.
As a USAA member for over three decades, I agreed with him. Why should USAA waste my premiums on subsidized business checking?!? Let the entrepreneurs pay for it out of their own cash flow!
About 15 minutes later, she raised her hand to deliver some feedback. “We just posted a question to our Facebook page: ‘What new USAA service would you most like to see?‘ We’ve had over 20 responses in the last few minutes, and the vast majority of them want business checking.” Silence filled the room. Finally the speaker asked the question that everyone else was thinking: “Why?”
It turns out that military spouses have a hard time keeping a job. Sure, they’re educated and hard-working. After running the family during a deployment, they certainly know how to supervise a team and get things done. But when you have to quit your job every 2-3 years to move to a new duty station, it’s hard to build a record that excites hiring managers. After confronting this issue a few times, many military spouses create their own jobs: they become entrepreneurs. Their sales bring in cash & checks, so they need a business checking account to handle the revenue.
But when you transfer every 2-3 years, especially overseas, it’s almost impossible to keep your business checking at your local bank. That’s why military spouses want USAA to offer business checking. They already trust the company for their insurance and their personal finances, and they’d like to keep their business with the same company.
To the speaker’s credit, Facebook’s feedback changed his mind. (This question got nearly 200 responses during the next 24 hours around the globe, and the vast majority wanted business checking.) Instead of seeing business checking as an expensive and highly-regulated money-losing convenience for a few niche users, now we all realized that it’s a desirable member service. So USAA is working the issue and they’ll let us know the timeline.
Here are other answers:
“Will the rates for the Flexible Retirement Savings Annuity and the Single Premium Immediate Annuity go up in 2012?”
I think the Federal Reserve’s recent policy announcements could already predict the short answer to this question: “Probably not.” USAA will continue to remain competitive with the rest of the annuity market, but they’re not able to just hand out the cash. Annuity rates will rise (or stay down) with the rest of the market’s interest rates. Service is where they expect to gain customer share.
“What does USAA have to do to get a long-time insurance customer to think of them more readily for their financial products instead of NFCU, Pentagon Federal Credit Union, Vanguard, & Fidelity?”
“USAA’s insurance rates are untouchable– how can we get the same cost/service package from investment and banking products?”
I spent almost an hour over frosty beverages interrogating Scott “Ask USAA” Halliwell and other staff about this issue. USAA is unlikely to compete on the market’s lowest expenses for their mortgages and investments.
First & foremost, USAA wants to be an insurance company with great member service. They’re not trying to undercut massive financial institutions like NFCU or Vanguard– because USAA will never have enough members or assets to drive those giants out of the market. Even worse, cutting USAA’s own rates for their mortgages & investments would initially simply shift that expense burden to the rest of the member premiums.
USAA sees service as their biggest product. Those of us who don’t want to pay for service will find better deals at the TSP and PenFed and Fidelity, and we don’t need USAA’s help. However, members who have been blissfully paying exorbitant fees to Bank of America Edward Jones other financial monoliths will get a huge price break at USAA. They may not find the lowest expenses, but they’ll enjoy service and trust. By not cutting their own profit margins to the bone, USAA can offer great service to a large group of people without raising premiums.
In the next post I’ll talk about another of their financial products that offers more great service.
“Is USAA insuring Hawaii homeowners again? What’s the plan for this hurricane season?”
Well, not yet. USAA will insure Hawaii first-time homebuyers, but my website request for a quote on our existing home was met with “We are unable to provide you an Insurance Policy because of an increased exposure from coastal storm-related damages.” USAA will keep writing policies as long as their risk is not excessively concentrated in a costly natural disaster like 1992’s Hurricane Iniki or the 2006 earthquake. That might take another year or two.
The bigger issue behind this question is comparing USAA’s insurance rates to other companies. The insurance industry has created a huge confusopoly among different products for home, auto, & liability with different coverage limits, deductibles, and rebates. Conveniently, Chuck Oakes’ team at the Innovation Center has developed a few ways to cut through the fog. First, USAA has developed applications to read the rate-quote sheets of other insurance companies. Customers can take a photo with their smartphone, send it to a USAA rep, and wait for a comparison to be sent back. Second, USAA’s computer network will automatically scan and interpret the image to break it down for the rep to complete the comparison. Third, reps are testing a method to respond to customers via Facebook and Twitter– in the same way they now respond by e-mail and on the phone.
That sounds great but you still have to enter some data on the website, maybe talk to a rep, and match some categories & deductibles from other companies to get a rate comparison. Wouldn’t it be even better if you could just log into your USAA account, click on the “Compare rates” link, and a few seconds later read the competition’s summary? Well, it’s technically feasible. Watch this blog for the update.
“Advertising seems to be on the rise. Is new customer growth paying for it, or is the cost being passed on to us current customers? Is the cost of acquiring new customers going up or down?”
“As your customer base widens, it would seem that the quality could also drop. I’m curious how USAA maintains their financial standards. More customers would equal more money for the execs, so it’s possible that exec’s interests could diverge from the customer’s interests.”
USAA was started in 1922 by a group of Army officers who couldn’t get life insurance. Although they expanded their eligibility over the years to include Air Force and even Navy officers, they didn’t extend the offer to enlisted servicemembers until 1996. “Opening the ranks” was quite a culture shock to the entrenched membership, and you can imagine the grumbling and harrumphing that went on among certain senior members. However, the demographic fact was that the military was drawing down over 25% from 1991 onward, and USAA’s membership wasn’t growing fast enough to keep up their financial strength.
Along with officers & enlisted members, eligibility was also extended to family and certain other categories. However, one of USAA’s staff told me that the number of exceptions and loopholes made qualification rather complicated, and the membership still wasn’t growing fast enough to enable USAA to offer all the services that a larger association could support. A rather straightforward solution was to expand eligibility to “former officers and enlisted personnel who separated and were honorably discharged.” That tripled the potential members to nearly 60 million veterans and their families. Even without membership, anyone is eligible to sign up for USAA’s investment products, credit cards, life insurance, and most checking and savings products.
While USAA was reaching out to more members, their marketing staff realized that they needed to do a better job of reaching out to their existing members. Insurance customers weren’t aware that USAA offered investment services, and banking customers weren’t aware of all of USAA’s insurance products. Direct-mail costs were rising but the products weren’t working very well. They eventually cut their direct-mail program in favor of marketing through the press, radio, and television (look for the commercials on YouTube).
The ad campaign is succeeding far beyond expectations. Awareness of USAA is up 40%, awareness of their features and other information is up 20%, and awareness through their website and social media (Facebook) is up 80%. Not only are new members flocking to USAA, but the ad campaign seems to be inspiring the newbies to a higher standard of behavior. A significant number of the new members are actually turning out to be better customers than the current members– fewer missed mortgage payments, better credit-card histories, and better records on auto loans.
More members, lower acquisition costs, fewer delinquencies. I can live with that. (Will members see a bigger premium rebate in December?) USAA’s rapid growth may slow for a while as they absorb the data. (They already have a backlog of mortgage refinancings.) Now that the rush of new members has peaked, it may take a year or two for their analysts to verify these early results.
We were also told that bonuses don’t depend on the number of customers or the revenue. Employee incentives are based on exceptional service & retention, not recruiting.
Once again, here’s the disclaimer for the bloggers who attended this conference: “My trip to San Antonio to participate in the Blogger Event was fully provided to me by USAA.” Their network security center might have been monitoring our tweets, but they couldn’t buy our silence!
Do you have more questions for USAA? Well, you can always “Ask Scott”. But if you’d rather remain anonymous then use the “Contact me” box or send me an e-mail. And if you have a complaint, please post it here!
USAA’s underwear secrets
(Oh, like you never wanted to write that headline?)
Does this post help? Sign up for more free military retirement tips via e-mail, Facebook, or Twitter!